A person’s life can be changed by a single phone call, a single goodbye, or by one decision to stop waiting at last. This emotion is at the heart of Luigi Neighbours’ first EP, “Right Person, Wrong Lifetime,” a highly personal project brought to life by experiences of grief, love, loneliness, change, and the courage to start over.
Born in the Netherlands and now starting a new phase of his life in London, Luigi Neighbours has the mindset of someone who has come to realize that time should not be taken for granted. The sudden death of his father in 2024 was a deeply painful moment of change. Instead of letting his grief shut the door on his music, Luigi used it to open a new one. Having traveled alone, writing in Norway, leaving home, and pursuing the sound that inspired his love of music all give this first album a clear sense of purpose. The bands that have influenced him—Nickelback, Daughtry, Lifehouse, and The Goo Goo Dolls- also indicate a warm, emotional style typical of 2000s alternative rock, but the story presented here is clearly his.
The honesty is the emotional heart of the EP. Instead of showing love as a perfect conclusion to a film, Luigi shows it as messy, delayed, fragile, full of hope, and at times painfully incomplete.
The title song, “Right Person, Wrong Lifetime”, expresses the main idea of the EP: love can be genuine and yet come at the wrong time. The song deals with timing, missed opportunities, and the harsh reality that deeply wanting something does not mean it will actually happen. Because it serves as the emotional highlight, it also embodies Luigi’s broader message concerning not putting off life. His way of singing matches this sense of honesty. Since it does not require a great deal of drama, the song demands sincerity, emotional control, and a voice as if there is something personal on the line. The rock foundation inspired by the 2000s gives the track a familiar and open-hearted quality, while the production backs up its theme without drawing attention away from the lyrics. I, as a listener, enjoyed every bit of the soundscape. The guitar is beautifully executed, and it is mind-blowing
“Surrogate You” enters the world of absence and longing. The title implies an effort to fill the gap left by a person who cannot actually be replaced, making the song one of the more vulnerable moments on the EP, with its focus on emotional substitution, loneliness, and the inherent need of humans for connection. Luigi’s performance is powerful when it sounds close and conversational rather than excessively polished; his voice becomes an integral part of the storytelling and conveys the pain of longing for someone who is not there. Musically, the song fits well within the EP’s guitar-based, emotionally straightforward style. Overall, this song has a bright, musical vibe that instantly hooks you in.
The song “Supernatural” introduces a different kind of love to the EP, emphasizing an attraction that comes across as particularly strong. It injects a sense of energy and romantic wonder into an EP which is mainly characterised by grief and reflection. This contrast is important. With this track, Luigi has to move past sadness, and the song provides him with the opportunity to sound more expressive and open. The production, based on the melodic rock style that clearly influences him, achieves a feeling of uplift without giving up the sincerity that is typical of the project. With its infectious groove and relatable lyrics, this is the kind of song that softly wins your heart.
Moving on, “Thank You” shows gratitude rather than regret. Since there is a background story associated with the EP, the song can be seen as a sincere and personal way of expressing thanks to someone whose influence remains even after their death. It is a type of song that calls for control; Luigi doesn’t have to exaggerate his emotions. The steady and genuine way he sings makes the feeling more believable, and the production supports the words rather than overpowering them. The piece sounds less like a performance and more like a message that had to be transported. Aside from the message, the musical arrangement in this song needs special note, as it lifts up the song to a higher heights!
In “Romance Isn’t Dead”, Luigi responds to cynicism. The song expresses a simple yet significant idea, namely that true connection still can take place, even though sincerity may seem outdated. This optimistic attitude provides the EP with room to breathe. Vocally, Luigi’s strength lies in the emotional clarity of his words. The influence of 2000s rock suits the song because it is centred on melody, emotion, and a heartfelt message. It is hopeful without becoming naive.
Lastly, “Out Of Tune” provides a genuinely human conclusion to the EP. The title implies a sense of disconnection, emotional imbalance, and the idea that something in a relationship or in life is no longer in the right place. As a closing track, it supports one of the EP’s main messages: that life is messy, people often lose their way, and not every situation can be corrected on time. Luigi’s vocal performance works most effectively when it shows this imperfection; the emotional honesty is more important than technical display, and this method gives the song a realistic sense of closure.
In “Right Person, Wrong Lifetime,” Luigi Neighbours creates a vocal style that starts with emotion. His real artistic strength does not lie in aiming to sound invulnerable, but in sounding human. Since the emotional aspect of the EP demands vulnerability, warmth, and conviction, these traits go well with his influences from 2000s rock. The production complies with the same principle: instead of trying to keep up with current trends, the EP is based on a melodic rock tradition which is known for strong songwriting, memorable hooks, and emotional guitar work. The balance between nostalgia and individuality gives the music its distinct identity. Although Luigi draws on a well-known period, the story of these songs is clearly his.
“Right Person, Wrong Lifetime” is, in the end, an EP concerned with deciding how to live following a loss. Luigi Neighbours doesn’t avoid his grief; instead, he uses it as the reason to keep going. Although his father’s absence casts a shadow over the EP, so too does the lesson learned from his death. Because of this, the band’s first record has a scope that goes beyond a simple set of songs; it is a mark of arrival, a tribute, and a promise to cease putting off the life that matters.
Listen to the “Right Person, Wrong Lifetime” EP on Spotify
Follow Luigi Neighbours here for more information
